We Need More 'Chief Sustainability Officers with Impact': Dr. Peter Gassmann/ PwC Germany on the 'real' powers and influence of Sustainability roles
In the dynamic landscape of corporate sustainability, the role of Chief Sustainability Officers (CSOs) within DAX-listed companies has evolved into distinct archetypes, reflecting diverse approaches and influences.
A PwC study led by Dr. Peter Gassmann identifies two categories of Chief Sustainability Officers (CSOs) among DAX-listed companies [The German stock index consisting of the 40 major German blue chip companies]: "CSO with impact" and "CSO light." Those with impact operate on the C-level, reporting directly to the CEO, and have the authority to drive comprehensive ESG transformations. The "CSO light" category includes those with less influence, often leading ESG initiatives within support functions.
The analysis introduces five CSO archetypes: CEO-CSO, C-level CSO, Standalone CSO, Core Business Function CSO, and Support Function CSO. The report emphasizes the importance of the CSO's organizational placement, asserting that a "CSO with impact" can significantly contribute to a successful ESG transformation beyond regulatory compliance, aligning ESG goals with long-term financial success and value creation.
Unveiling the Five Archetypes of Corporate Sustainability Leadership
In the dynamic landscape of corporate sustainability, the role of Chief Sustainability Officers (CSOs) within DAX-listed companies has evolved into distinct archetypes, reflecting diverse approaches and influences. The recent PwC study led by Dr. Peter Gassmann delves into the organizational structures, reporting lines, and responsibilities of CSOs, unveiling five key archetypes that offer insights into the varying degrees of impact on ESG (Environmental, Social, Governance) transformations:
"1. CEO-CSO: Pioneering Holistic ESG Transformation
CEOs who assume direct responsibility for ESG usher in profound transformations, embedding sustainability at the core of their company's purpose. Operating on an idealistic vision, these leaders believe in orchestrating the necessary changes to navigate stakeholder demands, aligning with customers, investors, employees, and interest groups.
2. C-level CSO: Strategic Sustainability Integration
This archetype involves a dedicated CSO reporting directly to the CEO, functioning as a crucial member of the top management team alongside roles like COO or CFO. By bringing sustainable strategies to the management board, these CSOs ensure that sustainability performance aligns with broader corporate goals. Variants may include an existing C-suite member taking on the CSO role, though effectiveness depends on tangible changes in tasks and actions.
3. Standalone CSO: Common Leader in ESG Education
The most prevalent type among the DAX, the Standalone CSO leads a team of experts across E, S, and G topics. While their influence might be more limited, they focus on educating business units, gaining buy-in, and implementing sustainability plans. Their mandate often extends beyond compliance, including developing ESG strategy, creating steering KPIs, and managing ESG reporting.
4. Core Business Function CSO: Tangible Impact on ESG Footprint
Embedded within a core business function, this CSO concentrates on transforming business activities to minimize environmental or social harm. Leveraging proximity to operational teams, they co-develop solutions, reflecting a pragmatic approach to ESG with a focus on quick, tangible impacts.
5. Support Function CSO: Initiating ESG from the Periphery
Positioned within support functions like finance, compliance, HR, or marketing, this CSO has a limited mandate and is often a beginner in ESG. Priorities include minimizing legal, safety, and reputational risks, meeting regulatory obligations, and conveying a commitment to ESG. Their ability to drive cultural or operational change is constrained.
Conclusion: The Imperative of CSO Impact on Financial Value
The PwC analysis underscores that half of the top-listed companies in Germany, Austria, and Switzerland have embraced the importance of ESG, particularly those with a "CSO with impact." While ESG challenges vary, the organizational placement of the CSO emerges as a critical enabler for successful ESG transformation. A "CSO with impact," reporting directly to the CEO, holds greater authority to articulate and achieve a shared vision of a company’s ESG goals, ensuring that ESG becomes integral to financial value creation. In essence, the CSO's role is pivotal in driving sustainability beyond regulatory compliance."
Read the full report below...
